Let’s learn the key differences between marketplace and ecommerce platforms to help you decide which path is right for your business. Find out the pros and cons of each option and make an informed decision for your online store.
Reading time: 9 min.
From deciding to start an online business, many considerations must first be discussed and weighed. One of the most important ones is choosing between the ecommerce and marketplace as an appropriate online business model.
There are differences between these models that can help businesses decide about the strategies they may want to steer toward with the alignment of goals and resources. This article will clarify what exactly draws the line between an ecommerce and marketplace, as well as delve into gathered pros and cons to help with your selection process.
What is an ecommerce platform?
Ecommerce denotes purchasing and selling items or services via an internet platform, generally through a uniquely operated store. It functions as a digital storefront as it provides businesses with full control over their branding, product catalog, and experience via customer services.
Characteristics of E-Commerce:
| Pros of E-Commerce | Cons of E-Commerce |
| Brand Authority: A standalone store allows businesses to establish a unique identity and build brand loyalty. | Initial Investment: High setup costs, including domain registration, website development, and marketing. |
| Customization: The ability to create a personalized shopping experience through tailored designs and features. | Traffic Generation: Requires significant effort to attract and retain visitors. |
| Customer Data: Direct access to customer behavior and preferences for better marketing strategies. | Maintenance: Ongoing management of the platform, inventory, and customer support. |
| Direct Profit Margins: No intermediary fees, leading to higher profitability per sale. |
E-commerce works perfectly for businesses wanting to distinguish themselves and have a direct relationship with their customers. It suits niche products, luxury products, and any business seeking to present a purely personalized shopping experience.
What is online marketplace?
Talking about what is marketplace, it is an online platform that connects different buyers to a seller. It means that sellers can offer their products or service to customers through this as a platform.
Pros of Online Marketplaces |
Cons of Online Marketplaces |
| Immediate Visibility: Access to an established audience without extensive marketing efforts. | Limited Control: Sellers must adhere to marketplace policies and have little say over branding. |
| Low Initial Costs: No need to develop a standalone website. | High Competition: Competing with other sellers offering similar products. |
| Streamlined Operations: The marketplace often handles payment processing and logistics. | Fees and Commissions: A percentage of sales is often taken as a commission. |
| Trust Factor: Established marketplaces have built-in credibility, which can attract customers. | Customer Ownership: The marketplace retains customer data, limiting direct interaction. |
Marketplaces work great for small businesses or individuals seeking a low-cost entry point. A marketplace is also good for volume-oriented businesses versus branding or those who want to test new products with no commitment toward a store.
E-commerce provides total ownership to the domain and the site, thus setting up a permanent digital asset for the business. Marketplaces, on the other hand, do not provide ownership; the seller becomes a tenant on the platform.
E-commerce has no bounds in terms of customization; businesses can personalize their shopping experiences. However, marketplaces only sell available templates and tend to allow minimal branding opportunities.
Marketplaces might be crowded with traffic that allows instant exposure to the sellers. E-commerce sites would need to depend on SEO, ads, marketing campaigns, and many others to drive traffic, which can take time.
Marketplaces have stiff competition for sellers as many vendors offer their goods, but an e-commerce setup can be defined as competition occurring on the broader internet across businesses but having full control over their unique positioning.
Most marketplaces offer integrated delivery systems into their platforms, which make logistics a simple process for sellers. Whereas e-commerce needs to build their shipping infrastructure, which may be quite challenging but also allows more personalized service.
There’s direct contact in an e-commerce environment between the store and the customer, while in a marketplace, everything is handled by a third party that does not allow sellers to build loyalty, nor get to know their customers that well.
Just when you’re thinking of starting an online store, the first thing you will need is the right e-commerce platform to build the store on if you intend to make it successful in the long run. Now, let’s review these five among probably the best e-commerce platforms available and why someone or some businesses would consider opting for one over the other.
It is one of the largest and most popular ecommerce platforms due to its simplicity and scalability. There are many library themes and integrations, thus making it a very suitable choice for both small and big businesses. The application is user-friendly and has all it needs for a single-outsource, easy-to-use solution, without looking into any technical details.
With the help of WooCommerce, a plugin, you can easily convert your already existing WordPress website into a full-on e-commerce shop. It’s versatile enough to let the business do what it needs to do within their own conditions. They are perfect for any business that has WordPress already, or any that wants a more personal and affordable option.
BigCommerce is a solid platform designed to allow solution growth and scalability. A built-in suite of SEO, multichannel selling, and advanced analytic tools is included within BigCommerce. Mid-sized and larger organizations that desire sophisticated capabilities to enable growth in operation while avoiding technical limitations will prefer this.
Magento is a strong platform for custom ecommerce experiences. The Magento platform is now part of Adobe Commerce. It is especially beneficial for large companies, having extensive resources in managing the technical part of its demands. It is a perfect choice for complex requirements with respect to processing huge technical data due to its strong methods.
It combines visual design with e-commerce functionality, which makes it a good option for creative professionals as well as small businesses. Great for those who put emphasis on the design part of their application with simple e-commerce features like art, fashion, or photography brands.
Because enabling businesses to reach a global audience must not necessarily entail investing heavily in developing their own platforms for e-commerce, here are five of the world’s most important online marketplaces, categorized according to their specific areas of interest.
The overwhelming largest and most popular e-mall is receiving millions of buyers from around the world. Its massive product catalog and customer-centric approach makes it the one single unmatched opportunity for sellers to reach such an audience. Amazon is the best option for people looking to grow their business quickly with an extremely large target audience-have high-demand category products.
eBay is now known more for its auctions and sales at fixed prices. It allows buyers to look for new and also old products, thus including almost every category. Ideal for sellers who are having unique products or collectibles and almost anything refurbished, eBay offers seller protection as buyer feedback systems and payment assurance. eBay would suit well for a business selling specific unique, previously used, or collectible items appealing to a niche audience.
Etsy is more of a site for artisans and small businesses. It matches all aspects of an individual-looking merchant as it deals with handcrafted, vintage, and craft items, making it very community on originality. It would be perfectly suitable for businesses selling handmade, vintage, or unique products targeting a creative niche audience.
Walmart, as an evolving Marketplace, permits third-party companies to market products through its site and, since this app is creating lots of utility, business firms will have it growing at their pace with access to American customers’ audience. Walmart Marketplace is an excellent choice for businesses seeking to enter or expand on the U.S. market, with high visibility and competitive fees.
Alibaba is one of the largest B2B online marketplace, connecting manufacturers and wholesalers to buyers all over the world, and particularly popular for bulk purchasing or international trade. It is most ideal for businesses wanting to buy their goods in bulk or globalize their supply sourcing; hence, it is a key platform for wholesale and manufacturing businesses.
The right questions asked will lead to choosing the most appropriate model according to your business objectives, since each model has its own advantages toward success.
Owning your store gives one hundred percent control in terms of branding, dealing with customers, and the overall experience. It allows you to create a unique appearance and feel that speaks to the audience which you intend to reach. Marketplaces in the other way grant instant access to millions of customers, meaning that products popular among the masses may sell quicker as compared to others.
If your customers predominantly shop on platforms like Amazon or eBay, listing your products on these online marketplaces gives you the best chance of reaching them. But If your target audience is niche and prefers personalized shopping experiences, having an ecommerce store could help you cater to their specific needs.
An ecommerce store typically requires a heavier investment at the start. You will have to pay for website development, design, hosting, and ongoing marketing for the acquisition of customers. By contrast, though, these are all developments that operate on a very low barrier of entry and often minimal start-up costs at marketplaces. You are on your way to selling almost instantly by making use of the built-in audience and marketplace marketing capabilities.
The debate of ecommerce vs marketplace comes down to your business’s unique needs and objectives. An ecommerce and marketplace each offers distinct advantages, and the right choice depends on factors like budget, audience, and branding priorities.
For business models already projected and those experts in customer retention, e-commerce as an entire concept would be the outcome. On the contrary, for business players looking to go for instantaneous visibility and trial on the markets, an online marketplace would capture the most benefit. Hence, weigh the pros against the cons, ask questions worth answering, and pick the ideal model for you.
The article explores AI's impact on ecommerce, highlighting its role in enhancing customer experiences and driving revenue.
This article helps store owners navigate their eCommerce tracking app search. You will find information about the top 5 best shipping software in 2023 – ShipStation, Shippo, AfterShip, EasyShip, and Narvar – and determine how well their key features, advantages, and cost work for you. Need more? Get a free consultation from our experts.
E-commerce is booming now. According to Statista, by 2022, global retail e-commerce sales will reach 6.54 trillion US dollars. And it’s twice more than in 2019.